This Can't Be Happening
Sites of Interest
(courtesy Empire Burlesque)
A Tiny Revolution
William Blum/Killing Hope
The Distant Ocean
Welcome to the Sideshow
Mark Crispin Miller
Crooks and Liars
Black Agenda Report
The Raw Story
Iraq Vets Against the War
Blues and Dreams
Bright Terrible Spirit
Actually it's all part of a pacification campaign Enbridge has launched in an attempt to qualm the legitimate and substantive concerns British Columbians have around the prospect of some 225 oil tankers, carrying oilsands crude from Alberta, annually navigating the narrow, rocky channels and inlets of the Great Bear Rainforest and pipelines crossing over 1,000 streams and rivers.
With 50 offices in 20 countries and affiliations with more than 70
associate companies, Hill and Knowlton is one of the world's largest
public relations firms. Hiring Hill and Knowlton speaks volumes about
the lengths to which Enbridge will apparently go to persuade the B.C.
public that supertankers and oilsands pipelines are a good thing for our
British journalist George Monbiot, of The Guardian, describes Hill and Knowlton as "the public relations company famous for the unsavoury nature of its clients." Monbiot points out that Hill and Knowlton "advised the Chinese government in the wake of the Tianenmen massacre, set up lobby groups for the tobacco companies and coached the girl who told the false story about Kuwaiti babies being thrown out of incubators, which helped to launch the first Gulf war."
According to Spin Watch, "The firm helped in the aftermath of the Exxon Valdez oil spill in Alaska and the Three Mile Island nuclear accident" and "has worked for governments with appalling human rights records, including Egypt, Haiti, Indonesia, Morocco."
Source Watch states
that "Phony Earth First! flyers and press releases calling for violence
during Redwood Summer were traced to PR giant Hill and Knowlton by San
Francisco Examiner columnist Rob Morse," at the height of the campaign
to prevent California's old growth redwood forests from being clearcut
by Pacific Lumber Company.
Hill and Knowlton was also hired by the B.C. Salmon Farmers Association several years ago to help convince British Columbians that open net cage fish farms were not a threat to our province's wild salmon stocks. In B.C., you would think Enbridge would have learned from the salmon farming industry that hiring expensive multinational PR companies does not make for better environmental practices, but only increases public suspicion of industries already suffering from a lack of trust.
The fact that Enbridge has enlisted Hill and Knowlton is not surprising, given the track record of collaboration. As the Globe and Mail reported in July 2010, as part of an effort to "restore its reputation" Enbridge hired Hill and Knowlton to "provide communications advice" after the Kalamazoo River spill. Given the harsh criticism leveled in the just released review of the Enbridge pipeline rupture in Michigan by the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board, all that "reputation recovery management," as they say in PR speak, has probably gone for naught.
What is remarkable is that Enbridge has engaged the services of Hill and Knowlton before the Northern Gateway project has even completed the regulatory review process -- this attempt to buy British Columbians' approval is an indication of desperation by a company that, despite having a massive war chest at their disposal, just can't win public approval in our province.
In the past year, Enbridge has lost key local governments in the province's north such as Terrace, Smithers and Prince Rupert, who now formally oppose the company's proposal. And they have attracted the opposition of southern local governments in politically important areas, the province-wide Union of B.C. Municipalities and the B.C. NDP.
Enbridge says their hope for the ad campaign is to "help British Columbians understand what the project is about," but being unable to change the fact oil spills happen all the time and pipelines simply don't create long-term jobs means they will continue to face an impenetrable wall in B.C. -- now they're just $5-million poorer.