Gaza Flotilla: The Media Battle in Israel
by TRNN
As the Flotilla boats to Gaza are prevented from leaving the Greek ports,
the Israeli government congratulates its diplomatic efforts in pressuring
Greece to stop the activists. Earlier in the week, the Israeli press cited an
army debrief when all major newspapers reported the Flotilla activists will
carry lethal acid on board their ships, according to army intelligence.
The
Real News' Lia Tarachansky questions Maj. Gen. Eitan Dangot, the
Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories, and the Minister of
Public Diplomacy and Diaspora Affairs, Yuli Edelstein . She also speaks
with Huweida Arraf, the Co-Founder of the Free Gaza Movement, and
Ofer Neiman, Editor of the Occupation Magazine about the Israeli
coverage of the Flotilla to Gaza, and the media battle between
government and activists.
Israeli press reports Gaza Flotilla will be carrying "lethal
acid" with "the intention of killing as many IDF soldiers as possible"
LIA TARACHANSKY,
TRNN: On Friday, the Greek leadership issued an order preventing the
flotilla boats from leaving its shores for Gaza. Israeli Prime Minister
Benjamin Netanyahu congratulated the Greek prime minister, George
Papandreou, in a speech on Thursday. According to an unnamed top Israeli
official, today there is a different Greece when it comes to Israel,
the organizers of the flotilla did not understand this, and now they're
paying the price. On Wednesday, the Government Press Office held a
briefing with Public Diplomacy and Diaspora Affairs Minister Yuli
Edelstein. YULI EDELSTEIN, MINISTER OF PUBLIC DIPLOMACY
AND DIASPORA AFFAIRS: First of all, we are not trying to hide. On the
contrary, we are proud that we've made a lot of diplomatic efforts in
different countries in order to explain to the governments, leaders,
people, the things that I've been just saying [snip] probably could
influence, you know, in the positive direction this whole intention of
coming with this violent and unnecessary flotilla.TARACHANSKY: On Saturday, Israeli activists gathered outside the Greek embassy in Tel Aviv to voice their opposition.CROWD: No justice! No peace! Shame on you Greece!
CROWD (SUBTITLED TRANSL.): Let the flotilla into Gaza! Send the traitors to jail!
TARACHANSKY:
[incompr.] the media battle between Israel and the coming flotilla
sharply escalated when the Israeli press reported flotilla activists
were carrying sulphuric acid with the intention of killing as many
Israeli soldiers as possible. The articles, which cited an army debrief
from Sunday night, portrayed the Free Gaza Movement as a front for
terrorists. Ofer Neiman is the editor of the Israeli Occupation Magazine.
OFER
NEIMAN, EDITOR, OCCUPATION MAGAZINE: It seems very orchestrated, I
mean, even more than previous affairs, like you said. All the main
newspapers, including Haaretz, coming out with pretty much the
same report as facts. If you use such a headline, "Coming to Kill",
they're coming to kill us, this amounts to a blood libel campaign
against the activists. What this says implicitly is that it's
permissible to kill the activists because they're coming to kill us.
TARACHANSKY: Two men were identified in this Maariv article as being linked to Hamas and were named as passengers on the flotilla.
EDELSTEIN: We are getting prepared. And when I say we, it's a very big we:
it's all the government ministries, it's the IDF, it's us on the front
of diplomacy, public diplomacy, information efforts. We are trying to
get ready for all the possible scenarios. We don't know how many people
of different persuasion will be there on these ships. We know for a fact
that the number of representatives of different terror groups, terror
organizations, are on their way to join the flotilla.
~~~TARACHANSKY:
According to the organizers of the flotilla, the two people that were
identified in the press as being linked to Hamas, Amin Abu Rashid and
Mohammed Ahmed Hanoun, they're not on the list of people to join the
boats. What's your comment on that?
EDELSTEIN: Well, if
that would be the case, I would be more than happy. My doubt is not
about these two specific Hamas terrorists. My doubt is whether they can
really--the organizers of these nice delegations coming from, you name
it, Ireland, Canada, United States, or wherever, whether they can really
be in that kind of control and can really, in real time, confront the
terrorists or unidentified people who will be joining the flotilla.
~~~TARACHANSKY:
The Real News spoke with Huweida Arraf, one of the founders of the Free
Gaza Movement, who organized nine previous attempts to break the siege
on Gaza.
HUWEIDA ARRAF, COFOUNDER, FREE GAZA MOVEMENT:
--another empty accusation by Israel. I am also the cofounder of the
International Solidarity Movement. I've been working in the occupied
territories with activists from all around the world for the last
decade. And this same accusation was thrown at us almost from the day of
our founding, that we support terror or enable terrorism, or that
people that come with us are terrorists. Israeli propaganda agents even
labeled our colleague that they killed, Rachel Corrie, you know, as a
terrorist supporter, and they blamed her for her own death, that she
jumped in front of a bulldozer. I mean, this is part of Israel's
propaganda, and there's absolutely no truth to that whatsoever.
TARACHANSKY: So you're not bringing on board Amin Abu Rashid and Mohammed Ahmed Hanoun?
ARRAF:
Well, first of all I should say that I do not in any way justify or
agree with Israel's claims that these two are terrorists in any way. And
we know that--how loosely Israel throws that term and everyone that it
throws that term at. However, no, both of those people have been
organizing, have been working to support the people of Palestine and the
people of Gaza in terms of the effort to break the siege on Gaza, but
they are not on our list of passengers.
~~~TARACHANSKY:
Yesterday I spoke to the Israeli army press woman, and she said, we
have no way of knowing what's on these ships, because we can't inspect
them in the countries that they're sailing from, because that would be
overstepping our territorial boundaries, but we also can inspect them at
sea.NEIMAN: Yeah. I mean, but he says that they do know
that there are various chemicals and terrorists and assassins on board
these ships. I mean, if that's what she said, that clearly indicates
that what they've been saying to the press is just propaganda.
~~~TARACHANSKY: Did you talk about whether you are bringing chemicals and what your intention with them is?
ARRAF:
I really don't know how they could have come to that conclusion.
There's absolutely no evidence of that whatsoever. Right now I am
collecting a list of cargo that have been donated by people, and that is
not on our list of cargo yet. However, if this agricultural supplies,
which might include some chemical fertilizer and otherwise, is donated, I
don't think we would have a problem taking that if it's not to be used,
thrown at anybody or used against soldiers, it is to be delivered to
the farmers of Gaza. But as of right now, to be clear, we do not have
that on our cargo list.
~~~TARACHANSKY: But
Neiman and Arraf are not the only ones charging the Israeli leadership
with spin. On Thursday, ministers from the Security Cabinet spoke out
against Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu and accused him of presenting
them with one version of intelligence and feeding another one to the
press. AFB reported one of the ministers as saying Netanyahu decided to
change the version about the nature of the flotilla for two reasons. The
first is for reasons of covering himself. If suddenly in the course of
the military operation something goes awry and there are casualties,
Israel will be able to say that it warned of that in advance. The second
reason is to apply pressure on the international community so that
governments will prevent the ships from leaving for the flotilla from
the outset. This is the second time this week that an internal struggle
in the Israeli leadership made it to the press. On Saturday, the
Government Press Office sent a letter to foreign journalists warning
them that if they cover the flotilla on board, they may be banned from
Israel for ten years. The next day, following an outcry from Knesset
members from his own party, Netanyahu recanted. Also speaking on
Wednesday was Major General Eitan Dangot, the coordinator of the
government activities in the occupied territories. After the flotilla
last year, Israel decided to allow the import of many items it
previously banned, such as cumin, dried fruit, and fishing rods. While
being questioned by journalists, Dangot denied that the drastic reversal
of Israel's ban on import had anything to do with last year's flotilla.
Dangot also denied that Israel's prohibition of trade in and out of
Gaza is based on a policy of economic warfare, something that the
diplomatic cables released by WikiLeaks revealed.
~~~TARACHANSKY:
Sorry. I mean in terms specifically as a policy of economic warfare, do
you think that because of the economic punishment, Hamas is weakened?
MAJ.
GEN. EITAN DANGOT, COORDINATOR, GOV'T ACTIVITIES IN THE TERRITORIES:
[incompr.] economic punishment. We are not talking about punishment of
population. We are talking about security needs. I think that today, or
as I say, after the deterrence of the last operation, when we have the
opportunity to extend the policy, and the result today, as you see, is
different. This is therefore the long-term policy. There are some times
that you have to close crossing while it is [incompr.] But no one has a
policy from the beginning to damage economy or individuals for someone
to live, but only under security needs and [incompr.]
~~~TARACHANSKY:
While Dangot was presenting data showing the number of trucks getting
into the Gaza Strip, he claimed Israel does not allow exports out of the
Gaza Strip, because it doesn't have the scanning equipment for security
checks. However, before the Hamas government was elected in 2006, 85
percent of the goods exported from the Strip were bound for Israel and
the West Bank. Gisha is an Israeli organization that works with Gazans
on the freedom of movement. In a recent press release, they said 83
percent of Gaza's factories are now closed or working at 50 percent or
less capacity. In the second part of this segment, we speak to Sari
Bashi, the executive director of Gisha, about the naval blockade on Gaza
and the easing of the siege as outlined by Major General Eitan Dangot.
End of TranscriptDISCLAIMER:
Please note that transcripts for The Real News Network are typed from a
recording of the program. TRNN cannot guarantee their complete
accuracy.
|