Written on the Body: The Progressive
Torture of Bradley Manning
by Chris Floyd
Tonight, in the tenth year of the 21st century, the government of the
United States is torturing a young man -- one of its own soldiers --
whom it has incarcerated but not indicted. He has been held in solitary
confinement for months on end, subjected to techniques of sleep
deprivation taken from the Soviet gulag, denied almost all human contact
except from interrogators, constantly harassed by guards to whom he
must answer every few minutes -- all in an attempt to break his mind,
destroy his will, degrade his humanity and force him to "confess" to a
broader "conspiracy" against state power.
His name is Bradley Manning. He is 23 years old. The "crime" he is
accused of committing is releasing video evidence of an American
atrocity committed years ago in Iraq: the murder of Iraqi civilians by
helicopter gunships.
Under the American system of jurisprudence, of
course, he is considered innocent until proven guilty of this heinous
'crime' of truth-telling. He has not been tried or convicted of this
charge, or any other crime.
Yet tonight, in the tenth year of the 21st century, in the United
States of America, under the leadership of the Nobel Peace Prize
laureate Barack Obama, 23-year-old Bradley Manning is being subjected to
same tortures routinely inflicted on other unindicted, untried captives
of the militarist state.
Journalist Andy Worthington, who has been one of the most thorough and assiduous chroniclers of the modern American gulag, has noted the parallels between
the treatment imposed on Manning and that doled out to earlier
prisoners of the bizarre, lawless limbo concocted by the American war
machine for those who threaten -- or are perceived to threaten -- its
ever-expanding, ever-more corrupt operations around the world.
Worthington states that the conditions of Manning's imprisonment
bear a marked and chilling resemblance to
the conditions in which a handful of US citizens and residents were
held as “enemy combatants” under the Bush administration. The key
elements here are the elements of profound isolation and suffering ...
not just the solitary confinement, with no other human being for
company, but also the refusal to allow Manning to have a pillow, sheets,
or any access to the outside world through the reporting of current
affairs.
It is these factors that mark out his
conditions of detention as sharing some key elements with the conditions
endured by the three “enemy combatants” held on the US mainland under
the Bush administration — the US citizens Yasser Hamdi and Jose Padilla,
and the US legal resident Ali al-Marri.
...
al-Marri, along with two American
citizens also held as “enemy combatants” — Yaser Hamdi and Jose Padilla —
was subjected to the same “Standard Operating Procedure” that was
applied to prisoners at Guantánamo during its most brutal phase, from
mid-2002 to mid-2004. This involved the use of “enhanced interrogation
techniques,” including prolonged isolation, painful stress positions,
exposure to extreme temperature, sleep deprivation, extreme sensory
deprivation, and threats of violence and death.
...
There is, at present, no suggestion that
Bradley Manning has been subjected to a wide range of “enhanced
interrogation techniques,” but prolonged isolation is confirmed, and
depriving him of a pillow, sheets, or any access to the outside world
through the reporting of current affairs are all elements of discomfort
and further isolation that were key to the program of belittling and
punishing “enemy combatants,” and, crucially, “softening them up” or
“breaking” them for interrogation. It is, sadly, all too easy to imagine
that other techniques designed to disorientate Manning and to further
erode his will — involving elements of sleep deprivation, threats and
sensory deprivation — could also be applied, or are, perhaps, already
being applied, especially if, as has been suggested by the Independent,
the authorities are hoping to cut a plea deal with him, reducing a
52-year sentence in exchange for a confession that Julian Assange of
WikiLeaks, whom the US is seeking to extradite to the US, was not just a
passive recipient of the information leaked by Manning, but was instead
a conspirator.
As Glenn Greenwald
and others have documented, the known treatment being meted out to
Bradley Manning is itself a profound form of torture. Indeed, isolation,
sleep deprivation, incessant harassment and constant interrogation were
primary methods of the torturers in the Soviet gulag, who in many cases
did not resort to more "enhanced" techniques unless the pressure was on
from above to produce large numbers of "convictions" and "evidence" of
conspiracies in a hurry. These techniques -- the same techniques now
used under the command of the Peace Laureate -- were considered highly
effective and severely punishing tortures in their own right. They are
now at the center of the American gulag's treatment of its captives.And,
as Worthington ominously notes, we have no way of knowing at this
moment whether "enhanced" techniques are being used on Manning as well.
I am running out of words to describe the depths we are sinking into.
I am running out of ways to try to shake people from their stupor and
shock them into an awareness of the monstrous evil that is rising all
around them. Even those who proclaim themselves the progressive friends
of all humankind spend most of their time and energy wringing their
hands over the political tea leaves, parsing the strategy and tactics of
the partisan squabbles between the two scarcely-distinguishable
factions of the militarist establishment. And while they are sometimes
bold enough to criticize this or that element of the Peace Laureate's
administration, they still fret and fight and pray to keep that
administration in power.
But tonight that very administration is torturing a young man --
torturing him -- for telling the truth about the crimes being committed
by the machinery of evil that their standard-bearer, the Peace Laureate,
now proudly directs. If you support this administration, then you
support the torture of Bradley Manning. You are working to guarantee
that such tortures, and worse, are inflicted on more and more
truth-tellers, more and more people whose consciences have been jolted
to the core by the abominations they have witnessed or learned about
from others.
The militarist, corporatist, liberty-stripping evil that our earnest
lovers of humanity fear will come to pass if those evil Republicans come
to power is already here, it is happening before their very eyes. "Oh,
that Glenn Beck, how terrible he is!" Yes, he is terrible, but I tell
you this: Glenn Beck hasn't tortured anyone. Glenn Beck hasn't killed
hundreds of defenseless innocent civilians, men, women and children
murdered without any warning by robot drones in an undeclared war on an
allied nation. Glenn Beck hasn't "surged" an endless, pointless,
murderous, money-making war of domination against a broken land and its
terrorized people. Glenn Beck is not going to court to defend torturers.
Glenn Beck is not proclaiming he has the arbitrary, unchallengeable
power to assassinate anyone on earth whenever he feels like it.
But the Peace Laureate has done all these things. He is
doing all these things, and more. No doubt Glenn Beck -- and all the
other greasy-pole climbers seeking wealth and domination in our degraded
society -- would like to do these things too. But those with their eyes
fixed on the potential or fantasized future evil of their partisan
opponents are blind to the fact that their own faction is committing
gross evils right here and now. Barack Obama is entrenching the
machinery of evil deeper and deeper into the structures of government
and society; he is strengthening the foundations of evil that others
will build upon, just as he is building upon the wars and gulags and
corporate whoredom of his predecessor. Progressives who support Obama --
who support this entrenching process -- are in fact guaranteeing that
their dystopian nightmares of the future will come true. They are
helping Obama clear the path for an even rougher, more merciless beast
now slouching toward Washington to be born.
As I said, words are beginning to fail me. And in any case, almost no
one is reading the words on this site. [Most of the traffic is drawn by
the magnificent -- and shattering -- collection of Iraq War photos
compiled by the webmaster, Rich Kastelein.] So let me end with the words
of someone else: the incomparable Arthur Silber, whose mighty heart and incisive mind have blazed with light through many dark years:
I repeat once more: these horrors are now
what the United States stands for. Thus, for every adult American, the
question is not, "Why do you obey?" but:
Why do you support?
Or will you refuse to give your support?
Will you say, "No"? These are the paramount questions at this moment in
history, and in the life of the United States. We all must answer them.
Our honor, our humanity, and our souls lie in the balance.
UPDATE: After putting this post together, I ran across the latest essay by Chris Hedges
at Truthdig. Hedges, like Silber, is one of the very few who have the
courage to walk the full walk and live fully by their convictions,
despite the cost. Hedges was recently arrested outside the White House
of the Peace Laureate, one of many protestors hauled off for speaking
the truth about the Laureate's wars in a manner deemed unseemly in our
great democracy.
His new piece is an eloquent description of how the nightmare
dystopia noted above is already coming into being, a horrible mash-up of
Huxley's "Brave New World" and Orwell's "1984." You should read the
whole thing, but here are a few excerpts, beginning with his mention of
the Bradley Manning case:
...The psychological torture of Pvt.
Bradley Manning—who has now been imprisoned for seven months without
being convicted of any crime—mirrors the breaking of the dissident
Winston Smith at the end of “1984.” Manning is being held as a “maximum
custody detainee” in the brig at Marine Corps Base Quantico, in
Virginia. He spends 23 of every 24 hours alone. He is denied exercise.
He cannot have a pillow or sheets for his bed. Army doctors have been
plying him with antidepressants. The cruder forms of torture of the
Gestapo have been replaced with refined Orwellian techniques, largely
developed by government psychologists, to turn dissidents like Manning
into vegetables. We break souls as well as bodies. It is more effective.
Now we can all be taken to Orwell’s dreaded Room 101 to become
compliant and harmless. These “special administrative measures” are
regularly imposed on our dissidents, including Syed Fahad Hashmi, who
was imprisoned under similar conditions for three years before going to
trial. The techniques have psychologically maimed thousands of detainees
in our black sites around the globe. They are the staple form of
control in our maximum security prisons where the corporate state makes
war on our most politically astute underclass—African-Americans.
...The public, at some point, will have
to face some very unpleasant truths. The good-paying jobs are not coming
back. The largest deficits in human history mean that we are trapped in
a debt peonage system that will be used by the corporate state to
eradicate the last vestiges of social protection for citizens, including
Social Security. The state has devolved from a capitalist democracy to
neo-feudalism. And when these truths become apparent, anger will replace
the corporate-imposed cheerful conformity. The bleakness of our
post-industrial pockets, where some 40 million Americans live in a state
of poverty and tens of millions in a category called “near poverty,”
coupled with the lack of credit to save families from foreclosures, bank
repossessions and bankruptcy from medical bills, means that inverted
totalitarianism will no longer work.
...
The noose is tightening. The era of
amusement is being replaced by the era of repression. Tens of millions
of citizens have had their e-mails and phone records turned over to the
government. We are the most monitored and spied-on citizenry in human
history. Many of us have our daily routine caught on dozens of security
cameras. Our proclivities and habits are recorded on the Internet. Our
profiles are electronically generated. Our bodies are patted down at
airports and filmed by scanners. And public service announcements, car
inspection stickers, and public transportation posters constantly urge
us to report suspicious activity. The enemy is everywhere.
Hedges also provides a telling passage from Orwell's novel, where the facts of life are explained to Winston Smith:
"We know that no one ever seizes power
with the intention of relinquishing it. Power is not a means; it is an
end. ... The object of persecution is persecution. The object of torture
is torture. The object of power is power.”
These bedrock truths of our time are now being played out on the body
and mind of Bradley Manning. The object of Bradley Manning's torture is
not bolstering "national security" or upholding the "rule of law"; the
object of his torture is the torture itself: the demonstration of power,
the enactment of power, the physical embodiment of power. Power is not a
reality until you exercise it -- inflict it -- upon someone else. And
that is the essential, the ultimate concern of the militarist empire
that rules us today.
*Go here to support Bradley Manning.*