And yet Taseko'
s proposal to kill the lake in the face of "specific
First Nations issues" and the "impact" (i.e. total elimination) on fish
habitat has been allowed to proceed.
In response, Taseko Lake Lodge’s owner said, “There is a biased play
going on within the government. We were pointedly denied in 2004 because
o
f First Nations and fish concerns. Six years later they are approving a
project that will not only kill…an entire ecosystem, it is entirely
opposed by First Nations….It is a rather insane project.” (
Globe and
Mail)
3. Liberal M.P. and Environment Critic Gerard Kennedy, “There doesn’t
seem to be any grounds the federal cabinet could use except simply
saying that when it comes to the environment and the economy, the
economy wins every time…That is the wrong message to send to Canadians
and
industry…industry is very capable of coming up with sustainable
proposals and we have to tilt things in that direction.
“You have to have some principals…
When the environment has no choice
but to lose out and you can’t offset it or mitigate it in some way, then
the environment has to win. That is the bottom line here.
“You have an area of claim by First Nations where there is no treaty and
that alone should cause things to come to a grinding halt. There has to
be respect for Aboriginal rights and the company should know that.”
4. And eloquently, from Chief Marilyn Baptiste of Xeni Gwet’in, “What
would you do if another country, many times more populous and powerful,
decides that it wants Canada’s water and, after listening to all the
reasons why it cannot not simply take it, announces that it is going to
do exactly that?
“Would you refuse to accept the country’s justification that its
hundreds of millions of people desperately need the water to sustain
their economy and that this outweighs any harm that would be done to the
relatively small Canadian population that stands in the way? Would you
expect your governments to resist? If your answers are yes, then you
have an idea of the position of the Tsilhqot’in people.
“……
If the government can sell out the Tsilhqot’in in this case, it
can sell out others too – and not just natives. Which is why, if denied
justice, we will be forced to act. It is why first nations across the
country see this as an issue of national importance. It is also why
Canadians have a vested interest in seeing our rights and way of life
protected. (
Globe and Mail)