What Osama bin Laden, Troy Davis, and You Have in Common
So, the United States invaded Mexico, lied about it, killed, raped,
pillaged, and stole half the country for the cause of expanding slavery
in our growing continental empire. Then a devastated rump Mexico was
invaded by the French who wanted their debts repaid, but the Mexicans
won a big battle against the French on the Fifth of May, leading
Americans to buy several tons of tacos and thousands of gallons of beer
every Cinco de Mayo. Viva international solidarity in the land of
Might-Makes-Right!
Secularists and Congressman Pete Stark have declared May 5th the Day
of Reason, but how many people know that, how many television stations
will stand for it, and how many Americans are even pretending to be
reasonable?
I've been reflecting during this Cinco de Mayo on exactly how
pervasive in my country is the idea that violence can solve all
problems.
I just watched a powerful documentary called
American Holocaust
about the war on Vietnam. Great footage and great narration by Martin
Sheen. The mission of the U.S. military in Vietnam was to kill as many
people as possible, and the currency became sliced-off ears. Bring back
the ears and get your pay from the U.S. government. That's how it
worked. Watch an officer admit to it in this film. Nowadays we
minimize death-counts instead of celebrating them, but in Afghanistan
fingers seem to have become the most common trophy among those
continuing the national tradition.
Almost every movie playing at any theater near me right now is
heavily violent. And the front page story in the local newspaper is a
nearby triple homicide. A Swedish movie that was recently a big hit
here and around the United States called "The Girl with the Dragon
Tattoo," involved a scene remarkably similar to a sick and sadistic
crime reported today from Oklahoma. And then there's Troy Davis.
Here's a good summary of the case of Troy Davis,
an almost certainly innocent black man likely to be killed soon by the
state of Georgia. Most of the world has abolished the death penalty,
including Canada, Mexico, all of Central America, half of South America,
all of Europe, Australia, and much of Africa and Asia. The big users
of the death penalty are the United States, China, and the nations we
call the Middle East.
What does Troy Davis have to do with Osama bin Laden? Davis is
widely believed to be innocent. Bin Laden was widely believed to be
guilty. Davis is an African American. Bin Laden was a foreigner, a
Muslim, and a terrorist. Davis is poor. Bin Laden was rich.
Democratic Party loyalists tolerate opposition to killing Davis but
condemn as treasonous and racist those who object to the killing of bin
Laden. Surely these cases have nothing in common.
An even more significant difference between the two cases would exist
if the initial lies coming out of the White House had not been so
swiftly retracted. That is, had bin Laden been killed in a fire fight
with people attempting to arrest him, his killing might be legal and
regretted. It appears, however, that he was killed unarmed in a swift
action aimed at killing him. And one can understand why that was
probably the plan.
Had bin Laden been given a trial as unfair as Troy Davis's treatment
by our judicial system, there would have been a huge uproar. Those who
believe in the rule of law would have objected to the unfairness. Those
who believe in the rule of violence would have objected to giving him
any trial at all. Those obsessed with the symbolism of closing
Guantanamo would have objected to holding him there. Holding him in
another illegal prison would have called attention (and possible
violence) to it. Holding him in the United States would have resulted
in impeachment proceedings and any number of Americans dying of heart
attacks. Instead bin Laden was killed.
Overturning Davis' conviction would similarly expose a very flawed
process. Proceeding with killing Davis, as with bin Laden, is viewed by
those in power as a cleaner, less messy, solution. Put the matter
behind us, they say, by murdering a human being. Caring for Davis comes
easily to us; it involves the sort of effort that Jesus of Nazareth
dismissed as unworthy of praise. Caring for bin Laden is not just
difficult but almost universally condemned as malicious and disloyal.
Yet that is what Jesus told us needed to be done.
Now, I oppose caring for anyone at the expense of others. Letting
bin Laden off the hook would send the wrong message to potential future
criminals. Prosecuting him in court would send the right one. But what
about executing him in his Pakistani home? What message does that
send? Primarily, the same one that killing Davis in a Georgia prison
sends: might makes right. Murder makes justice. War is peace. Life is
a superhero cartoon and your government is the superhero.
And what does this have to do with you and me? Well, we have to live
in the most violent wealthy nation on earth. We have to live in close
proximity to heavily armed people thrown out of work and out of house
and home, people trained to believe that violence can solve their
problems, people conditioned to use violence in our foreign wars and
then never reconditioned afterwards. This puts us all at risk.
We will not solve this by picking which acts of violence to protest.
We will solve it by opposing violence.