Ed Vitagliano is the â€œnewsâ€ editor of the American Family Association Journal. Heâ€™s also the AFA â€œresearcherâ€ who started the gay SpongeBob fiasco, and heâ€™s still hunting gays and suggesting new ways to demean them. His tactics focus on thwarting understanding and encouraging ignorance.
In a recent article Mr. Vitagliano took aim at public education:
The influence of homosexual activists within the nationâ€™s educational system continues to grow, altering the attitudes of children and teens toward the acceptance of a destructive and depraved lifestyle.
Often without parental knowledge, local schools are instituting policy changes that not only promote respect for homosexuality, but often even celebrate it. â€¦ [italics added]
What could be more â€œdestructive and depravedâ€ than a man dedicated to demeaning young gay people and encouraging prejudice against them?
Examine his statements, beginning with â€œoften without parental knowledge.â€ Clearly, Mr. Vitagliano wants parents notified so that those who share his parochial, prejudiced views can raise Cain with school officials and local school boards. He urged these like â€œmindsâ€ to participate in the Standard of Liberty Foundationâ€™s â€œRisk Audit Projectâ€ (RAP):
In May and June 2005, over 50 state pro-family groups formed an alliance to encourage the Southern Baptist Convention to use its influence to protect children from school districts that are promoting acceptance of homosexual behavior. As a result, a resolution was passed that encouraged local SBC churches to investigate, among other things, whether their school district is betraying parents, children, and the community by collaborating with homosexual activists. In cases where the school district was found to be collaborating, the resolution also urged parents to hold the school districts accountable and demand discontinuation of such morally offensive programs and materials.
As a result, to assist this investigative effort, we are offering this survey instrument to implement what we call the â€œRisk Audit Project.â€ The objectives of the Project are to:
1. Gather information about school districts throughout the U.S. regarding whether and how the districts promote acceptance of homosexual behavior to students;
2. Summarize this information through use of a uniform research instrument;
3. Communicate the results to the public through various media;
4. Hold the identified schools accountable to make needed changes in curricula; school programs and policies; and teaching.
Sound like McCarthyism to you?
The Risk Audit Project claims that what it â€œoffers local communities is knowledge.â€ Nothing could be further from the truth, beginning with their claim that homosexuality is one of several â€œmental health disorders.â€
Aside from the fact that the American Medical Association, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Psychological Association, the American Psychiatric Association, the American Counseling Association, the National Association of School Psychologists, and the National Association of Social Workers strongly disagree, the Risk Audit Projectâ€™s blatant lie â€“ there is no more accurate word â€“ is part of other misrepresentations and distortions:
The fact remains that teens engaging in homosexual behavior are participating in a lifestyle that:
â€¢ reduces life expectancy at age twenty by at least 8 to 20 years
â€¢ increases by at least 500% the risk of contracting AIDS
â€¢ increases the risk of contracting a sexually transmitted disease by nearly 900%
â€¢ increases by 4,000% the risk of developing anal cancer
â€¢ substantially increases the likelihood of smoking, having mental health disorders (other than same-sex attraction), being the victim of â€œdomesticâ€ violence, and being involved in alcohol and drug abuse
â€¢ substantially increases the likelihood of contracting hepatitis and other gastrointestinal infections
â€¢ substantially increases the risk of contracting bacterial vaginosis, breast cancer, and ovarian cancer
â€¢ has high levels of participation in sadomasochism, coprophilia, sadomasochism, fisting, and other dangerous, deviant sex practices
â€¢ involves extraordinarily high levels of promiscuity
â€œContracting breast cancerâ€?
RAP lists two references in relation to these scare tactics. One of them is â€œThe Health Risks of Gay Sexâ€ by John R. Diggs, M.D. The author is well known for using misleading â€œstatisticsâ€ and more often than not basing seemingly â€œprofessional opinionsâ€ on personal beliefs and biases. Dr. Diggs and this particular article were the subject of â€œMedical Advice with Mixed Messages,â€ Parts I, II and III.
The other â€œsourceâ€ is an article by Timothy J. Dailey, Ph. D. that appeared on the website of Tony Perkinsâ€™ Family Research Council. FRC is the faith-based ultra-conservative group that sponsored the theocracy-on-parade Justice Sunday events (JS I, JS II, JS III). At least they had the authenticity to add the following notation to Daileyâ€™s article: â€œPlease note: this article is an archived item on Family Research Councilâ€™s website; the information contained therein may be outdated.â€ Outdated and misleading, to be sure. But they forgot â€œhomophobic.â€ The Risk Audit Project cited the article as if it were current research.
Some of what the Risk Audit Project considers dangerous includes â€œAn anti-harassment, anti-bullying or â€˜safe schoolsâ€™ policy that includes the category â€˜sexual orientation,â€™â€ â€œNon-discrimination policy based on â€˜sexual orientationâ€™ (may also cover â€˜gender identityâ€™) for students and/or teachers, staff,â€ â€œRequirements for teacher/ staff training on â€˜diversity,â€™ â€˜tolerance,â€™ â€˜sensitivity,â€™â€ â€œPrograms on tolerance, diversity, â€˜hateâ€™ or â€˜bias,â€™â€ â€œLessons on different types of families,â€ â€œHIV/AIDS and â€˜safe sexâ€™ education programs,â€ â€œPolitical Science/ History/Civics classes on current issues.â€
Thatâ€™s right. These homophobic McCarthyites consider â€œPolitical Science/ History/Civics classes on current issuesâ€ dangerous. God forbid students should be informed about current events and issues. After all, theyâ€™ll be old enough to vote after graduation or even during their senior year. But perhaps thatâ€™s the point: keep them uninformed so theyâ€™re more likely to accept platitudes and propaganda. Discriminationâ€™s worst enemy is knowledge; bigotryâ€™s, critical thinking.
Note the nature of the other things RAP considers dangerous: a safe learning environment for all students, equality among public school personnel and, of course, real-world sex education. Their â€œreasoningâ€ on the last one defies all knowledge and logic: â€œThese lessons assume all students are at risk of AIDS; that all students need to be taught about use of condoms for â€˜safe sex.â€™â€ All sexually active students are at risk not only for HIV infection but a host of other STDs. Not informing them about condom use is nothing short of criminal.
Much of the Risk Audit form is designed to gather specific information about schools, principals, school board members, curricula, and extra-curricular options. All this information is then to be â€œturned inâ€ so appropriate â€œactionâ€ can be taken.
One of Vitaglianoâ€™s primary targets in his article was Gay-Straight Alliance (GSA) clubs. As before, the Homo Hunter began his assault on â€œthe problem of GSAsâ€ with parental notification:
These clubs are often formed without parental notification or input. Kids who consider themselves homosexual â€“ or straight kids who are sympathetic to the homosexual movement â€“ simply have to approach school administrators and obtain permission. Because most schools allow the formation of non-academic student groups, federal equal access laws often require schools to allow GSAs.
Once these groups get started, students are allowed to gather regularly at school and promote their meetings and their views using the schoolâ€™s public address system, bulletin boards and copy machines.
Would Mr. Vitagliano have the same concern about schools allowing students to form Christian clubs? How about Islamic clubs? Ethnic clubs? Racial clubs? Would he support racist parents who object to African-America clubs? Would he support parents whose religious bigotry would prompt them to object to Islamic, Buddhist, or Jewish clubs?
Recall one of Vitaglianoâ€™s opening statements in his article: â€œlocal schools are instituting policy changes that not only promote respect for homosexuality, but often even celebrate it. â€¦â€ [italics added]
GSA clubs are dedicated to promoting respect for all students: the very thing that Vitagliano abhors. He wishes to promote disrespect and contempt by thwarting understanding and encouraging ignorance. One can only assume heâ€™s supportive of the violence to which disrespect and contempt inevitably lead.
â€œCelebrateâ€? Thatâ€™s Vitaglianoâ€™s spin meant to divide and conquer using the ignorance born of fear and hate. What he canâ€™t bear is acknowledging the legitimacy of respect for all people. A similarly depraved â€œhuman beingâ€ used a similar point of view in his allegedly Christian campaign to purify his nation and rid it of â€œundesirables.â€ Mr. Vitagliano might even tacitly approve of the faith-based ideology in the Talibanâ€™s recently issued â€œcode of conductâ€ that includes â€œwhen to kill teachersâ€ who propagate respect for all people. After all, recognizing every personâ€™s basic human dignity and fundamental civil rights is anathema in both a fascist and a theofascist state.
Supporting Vitagliano in his campaigns is the founder and chairman of the American Family Association, Don Wildmon, whoâ€™s in the Schadenfreude business of hurting gay and lesbian families. Wildmon and the AFA are notorious for launching campaigns against any organization or company that supports equality. Their latest target is Sears. The companyâ€™s crime against Wildmon World is that â€œSears Supports Homosexual TV Network With Advertising.â€
The AFAâ€™s leaderâ€™s â€œcall to actionâ€ ended with urging his sheeple to
1. Send an email to Sears asking them to cancel their advertising on LOGO.
2. Call your local Sears store and ask why Sears is supporting the homosexual network with its advertising.
3. Forward this email to your friends and family.
LOGO is not a broadcast channel. In most cases, someone
would have to subscribe to cable (often digital cable) or satellite TV in order
to get LOGO, and both cable and satellite systems have â€œparental controlsâ€ that
would enable subscribers to block the channel if they wanted to. But thatâ€™s not
the point. Wildmon doesnâ€™t want LOGO to exist or gay people to be recognized in
Sears is only one of eighty national advertisers on LOGO. Some others include American Express, Intel, Kodak, Lexus, and Pepsi. One has to wonder why Wildmon singled out Sears. Could it be part of his overall strategy against major retailers?
Before Thanksgiving Wildmonâ€™s American Family Association had called on Christian consumers to spend their dollars elsewhere as a sign of their displeasure with Wal-Martâ€™s pro-homosexual leanings, says the nationâ€™s largest retailer is not just working with the homosexual agenda of the NGLCC [National Gay and Lesbian Chamber of Commerce], it is promoting it. As proof, AFA offers up examples of books available for purchase through Wal-Martâ€™s online bookstore â€“ books the pro-family group contends support or defend homosexuality. â€¦
In an â€œAction Alertâ€ to its supporters on Monday (October 23), AFA identifies several book titles available through Walmart.com that it says relate to the promotion of homosexual marriage â€“ among them are: What God Has Joined Together: The Christian Case for Gay Marriage; Legalizing Gay Marriage; Gay Marriage and Democracy: Equality for All; Defending Same-Sex Marriage; and Gay Marriage, Real Life: Ten Stories of Love and Family.
In addition, AFA states it found (via a search function at Walmart.com) more than 1,100 items for sale when the term â€œgayâ€ was entered, almost 500 in response to the term â€œlesbianâ€ â€¦
How very appropriate AFA offered up â€œexamples of books.â€ The Nazis also found books threatening, so threatening that they had to burn them.
Wildmon and the AFA were also angry with Wal-Mart for the companyâ€™s support for the Gay and Lesbian Chamber of Commerce, for expanding its definition of â€œimmediate familyâ€ to include an employee's same-sex partner, and for practicing workplace equality: all heinous crimes in Wildmon World.
Wildmonâ€™s â€œAction Alertâ€ about Sears ended with a one-sentence paragraph: â€œSears is owned by Kmart Corporation.â€ His former Wal-Mart â€œAction Alertâ€ prompted the more fanatical sheeple in the flock to launch a boycott of the retail chain. How long will it be until some â€œChristian leader,â€ prompted by Wildmonâ€™s missive, calls for a boycott of Sears and Kmart Corporation?
Wildmonâ€™s American Family Association thrives on such boycotts meant to hurt businesses â€“ and the families they support â€“ if the company treats all its employees equally and/or advocate civil equality for all Americans.
In a June 2, 2006 article carried by AFAâ€™s propaganda organ Agape Press, supposedly â€œpro-familyâ€ Wildmon claimed that AFAâ€™s boycott was hurting the Ford Motor Company. The â€œpro-familyâ€ designation is blatantly fraudulent, hypocritical and, in this case, nothing less than malevolent. How many families â€“ including Christian and â€œtraditionalâ€ ones â€“ are adversely affecting by this â€œpro-familyâ€ boycott and the destructive social bigotry it inspires?
Does Wildmon and the AFA care?
Obviously they donâ€™t give a damn.
That was made clear by Rev. Wildmon in his mid-June 2006 statement:
The American Family Association says that its boycott of Ford Motor Company over the automakerâ€™s support for LGBT issues is having an impact.
â€œThe boycott of Ford Motor Company is working! Sales of automobiles made by Ford dropped 2% in May,â€ AFA chair Donald E. Wildmon said in an email to supporters.
What kind of man, what kind of â€œChristianâ€ would take pleasure â€“ note Wildmonâ€™s excited exclamation point â€“ in hurting people and their families?
Mr. Vitagliano and Rev.Wildmon seem little more than pathetic caricatures of sick men who enjoy trying to hurt other people while hiding behind â€œreligion.â€ As John Shelby Spong lamented, â€œOur society gives wide berth to obvious pathology when it is covered by religious language.â€
The Right Reverend Spong is the retired bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Newark and author of fourteen books, including the bestsellers Rescuing the Bible From Fundamentalism and Why Christianity Must Change or Die. Both books â€“ along with Rev. Spongâ€™s essay â€œNo Room for Compromise: Christianityâ€™s integrity rides on how religious people deal with gay rightsâ€ â€“ should be under Vitaglianoâ€™s and Wildmonâ€™s â€œChristmas tree.â€